About CJA
Our History
Our Mission
Who We Are
Awards & Honors

Published Pieces

Testimony

Judicial Selection
Federal
State-NY

Judicial Discipline
Federal
State-NY

Test Cases:
Federal (Mangano)
State (Commission)

"Disruption of Congress"
Paper Trail to Jail
Paper Trail from Jail
The Appeals

Judicial Compensation
Federal
State-NY

Elections:
Informing the Voters

Press Suppression

Suing The New York Times
Outreach
Background Paper Trail

Searching for Champions:
    (Correspondence):

Federal
NYS
Bar Associations
Academia
Organizations
Nader & Others
Citizens

Our Members' Efforts

Library

Join Us!

THE "MERIT SELECTION"
OF WESTCHESTER DISTRICT ATTORNEY DiFIORE
AS NEW YORK'S HIGHEST JUDGE--

THE NOMINATION "PROCESS"

---------------------
click here forBACKGROUND:  23 years of EVIDENCE  of
the corrupted "process" of "merit selection"
to the New York Court of Appeals

---------------------

 

Step 1. 
Commission on Judicial Nomination

Commission on Judicial Nomination's May 12, 2015 press release of Chief Judge vacancy

Commission on Judicial Nomination's June 3, 2015 press release: "The Road to the Court of Appeals: Demystifying the Process"

Commission on Judicial Nomination's October 15, 2015 press release, letter to Governor & report 
 

 

Step 2.  
Bar Associations

November 6, 2015: New York City Bar Association
Janet DiFiore                         “Well Qualified“
Carey R. Dunne                     “Well Qualified"
Michael J. Garcia                   “Well Qualified”
Caitlin J. Halligan                   “Well Qualified”
A. Gail Prudenti                     “Well Qualified”
Rowan D. Wilson                   “Well Qualified”
Stephen P. Younger              “Well Qualified”


November 8, 2015:
NYS Academy of Trial Lawyers

Janet DiFiore                         “Recommended “
Carey R. Dunne                     “Recommended”
Michael J. Garcia                   “Recommended”
Caitlin J. Halligan                   “Most Highly Recommended”
A. Gail Prudenti                     “Highly Recommended”
Rowan D. Wilson                   “Highly Recommended”
Stephen P. Younger              “Most Highly Recommended”


November 9, 2015: Tri-County Bar Association  & here
Janet DiFiore                         “Highly Qualified “
Carey R. Dunne                     “Highly Qualified”
Michael J. Garcia                   “Highly Qualified”
Caitlin J. Halligan                   “Qualified”
A. Gail Prudenti                     “Highly Qualified”
Rowan D. Wilson                   “Highly Qualified”
Stephen P. Younger              “Highly Qualified”

November 9, 2015: Albany County Bar Association
Janet DiFiore                         “Qualified “
Carey R. Dunne                     “Qualified”
Michael J. Garcia                   “Highly Qualified”
Caitlin J. Halligan                   “Qualified”
A. Gail Prudenti                     “Qualified”
Rowan D. Wilson                   “Highly Qualified”
Stephen P. Younger              “Highly Qualified”

Broome County Bar Association
Janet DiFiore                         “Highly Qualified “
Carey R. Dunne                     “Highly Qualified”
Michael J. Garcia                   “Qualified”
Caitlin J. Halligan                   “Qualified”
A. Gail Prudenti                     “Highly Qualified”
Rowan D. Wilson                   “Qualified”
Stephen P. Younger              “Highly Qualified”

November 10, 2015:
Women Trial Lawyers Caucus
Janet DiFiore              “Highly Qualified “
Carey R. Dunne                     “Qualified”
Michael J. Garcia                   “Qualified”
Caitlin J. Halligan                   “Qualified”
A. Gail Prudenti         “Highly Qualified”
Rowan D. Wilson                   “Qualified”
Stephen P. Younger        "Highly Qualified”


 November 10, 2015:
New York State Bar Association  letter to Governor
Janet DiFiore                         “Qualified “
Carey R. Dunne                     “Qualified”
Michael J. Garcia                   “Qualified”
Caitlin J. Halligan                   “Well Qualified”
A. Gail Prudenti                     “Well Qualified”
Rowan D. Wilson                   “Qualified”
Stephen P. Younger              “Well Qualified”

 November 10, 2015: New York State Trial Lawyers Association
Janet DiFiore...“Highly Qualified & Highly Recommended“
Carey R. Dunne......................"Qualified”
Michael J. Garcia............“Qualified & Recommended”
Caitlin J. Halligan........."Qualified & Recommended”
A. Gail Prudenti..............“Highly Qualified & Highly Recommended”
Rowan D. Wilson............“Highly Qualified & Highly Recommended”
Stephen P. Younger.......“Highly Qualified & Highly Recommended”

 

Step 3. 
Governor

Governor's December 1, 2015 press announcment

NYS Bar Association's December 1, 2015 Statement


click here for:

Steps 4 & 5 -- Senate confirmation

 

click here for:  

MENU PAGES ON THE "MERIT SELECTION"
OF D.A. DiFIORE AS NY's CHIEF JUDGE

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

*   *   *

 

Press Reporting

October 10, 2015: "Janet DiFiore on list of potential N.Y. Court of Appeals candidates", Gannett (Joseph Spector)

October 15, 2015:  "DiFiore: "I would be privileged to serve", Gannett-LoHud  (Joseph Spector)

October 16, 2015: "Practitioners Dominate Chief Judge Nominee List" (Joel Stashenko)

November 12, 2015: "DiFiore not among top qualified candidates for chief judge, Bar Association says", Gannett (Democrat & Chronicle)  (Joseph Spector)

December 6, 2015: "Judging the judge as Janet DiFiore seeks top judge spot" Daily News editorial

December 30, 2015: "New year to begin with judge shortage on NY high court", North Country Public Radio  (Karen DeWitt)

January 4, 2016: "
Court of Appeals Resumes With Only Five Judges", New York Law Journal (Joel Stashenko)

January 4, 2016: "Dereliction of Duty in Albany", Daily News editorial

January 6, 2016: "DiFiore's court screening set for Jan. 20", Journal News-Gannett (Jon Campbell)

January 7, 2016: "Confirmation Hearing Set For DiFiore as Chief Judge", New York Law Journal (Joel Stashenko)

January 7, 2016: "Former Chief Judge Lippman gets new gig", Gannett (Jon Campbell)

January 8, 2016:  "Senator: Can DiFiore be independent of Cuomo as chief judge?",  Gannett (LoHud) (Joseph Spector)

January 17, 2016: "Cuomo ally Janet DiFiore up for approval as top judge", Newsday (Yancey Roy)

January 19, 2016: "DiFiore to face Senate hearing on Wednesday", Gannett (Jon Campbell)

 

 

January 19, 2016:  "Janet DiFiore: Part 2 -- The Confirmation Hearing" (Vincent Bonaventre) -- caution, you are entering a spin zone

 

 

*   *   *

click here for:  

MENU PAGES ON THE "MERIT SELECTION" OF D.A. DiFIORE



 

 

Top

 
CJA Site Search Engine Search CJA

CJA Homepage  •  Latest News  •  Join Us  •  Site Search

 

 

Post Office Box 8101, White Plains, New York 10602
Tel: (914) 421-1200
e-mail: mail@judgewatch.org