Record from McKinney & St. Joseph Hospital --
accompanying Plaintiff-Appellants' March 26, 2019 letter to the Court of Appeals,
in support of their appeal of right

Mary McKinney, et al. v
Commissioner of the New York State Dept. of Health, et al.

Supreme Court/Bronx Co. March 8, 2007 Decision -- here
Appellate Division, First Dept. June 19, 2007 Decision -- here

Court of Appeals' September 6, 2007 decision, dismissing appeal of right, "sua sponte, upon the ground that no substantial constitutional question is directly involved"

Court of Appeals' November 27, 2007 decision
 granting Association of the Bar of the City of New York permission to file amicus brief

Court of Appeals' November 27, 2007 decision
denying leave to appeal

INVENTORY – MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL

September 20, 2017:   Plaintiff-Appellants’ Notice of Motion for Leave to Appeal

October 3, 2017:         New York City Bar Association’s Notice of Motion for Leave to File
                                  Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Plaintiff-Appellants’ Motion for
                                  Leave to Appeal – & proposed Amicus Curiae Brief

St. Joseph Hospital of Cheektowaga, et al.
v. Novello, et al.

Supreme Court/Erie Co. February 2, 2007 Decision -- here
Appellate Division, Fourth Dept. July 18, 2007 Decision -- here

Court of Appeals' November 27, 2007 decision dismissing appeal, of right, "sua sponte, upon the ground that no substantial constitutional question is directly involved."

INVENTORY – APPEAL OF RIGHT      
 

July 23, 2007:             Plaintiff-Appellants’ Notice of Appeal

August 1, 2007:          Plaintiff-Appellants’ Preliminary Appeal Statement

August 1, 2007:          Plaintiff-Appellants’ Notice of Challenge to Constitutionality of
                                  a Statute

August 8, 2007:          Court of Appeals letter from the Deputy Clerk

August 16, 2007:        Plaintiff-Appellants’ letter in support of appeal of right

August 17, 2007:        Attorney General’s letter  opposition to appeal of right

August 21, 2007:        Plaintiff-Appellants’ letter in reply & in further support

November 27, 2007:   Court of Appeals Decision & Order

November 28, 2007:   Attorney General’s Notice of Entry

INVENTORY – MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL 

November 30, 2007:   Plaintiff-Appellants’ Motion for Leave to Appeal

December 10, 2007:    Attorney General’s Memorandum in Opposition

February 12, 2008:      Court of Appeals Decision & Order

February 13, 2008:      Attorney General’s Notice of Entry

*  *  *

click here for:
RECORD:  CJA's SECOND citizen-taxpayer action