About CJA
Our History
Our Mission
Who We Are
Awards & Honors

Published Pieces

Testimony

Judicial Selection
Federal
State-NY

Judicial Discipline
Federal
State-NY

Test Cases:
Federal (Mangano)
State (Commission)

"Disruption of Congress"
Paper Trail to Jail
Paper Trail from Jail
The Appeals

Judicial Compensation
Federal
State-NY

Elections:
Informing the Voters

Press Suppression

Suing The New York Times
Outreach
Background Paper Trail

Searching for Champions:
    (Correspondence):

Federal
NYS
Bar Associations
Academia
Organizations
Nader & Others
Citizens

Our Members' Efforts

Library

Join Us!

[background: 2013-2020 -- Assembly Judiciary Committee]

2021 ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY COMMITTEE --
& ITS IMPEACHMENT INVESTIGATION OF GOV. CUOMO


NO ANNUAL REPORT FOR 2020 -- here's 2019 ANNUAL REPORT
"The Committee also shares budgetary oversight of the Office of Court Administration
and the Department of Law with the Assembly Ways and Means Committee."

Here's the Committee's ZERO "budgetary oversight"
over the OCA & AG FY2021-22 budget,
as established by the agendas of its committee meetings --

  Jan. 20th, Jan. 26th, March 2nd, and March 15th meeting agendas;  March 24th meeting agenda

& this, in face of
CJA's testimony at Legislature's February 10, 2021 "public protection" budget hearing
in the presence of Assembly Judiciary Committee Chair Lavine

* * *

 


CJA's May 25, 2021 e-mail to
ALL Assembly Judiciary Committee Members
--
"Emergency Action & Oversight Required:
The Assembly's taxpayer-paid counsel, Davis Polk,
is in breach of its contract & its publicly-made promises
to safeguard vs conflicts of interest in investigating
whether Gov. Cuomo commited impeachable acts"

1. 
GETTING THE ASSEMBLY's CONTRACT with DAVIS POLK

CJA's March 22, 2021 FOIL request to the Assembly & Comptroller --
"retention of Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP for Assembly's impeachment investigation of Gov. Cuomo"

Assembly's March 29, 2021 acknowledgment

CJA's April 29, 2021 FOIL request to Assembly & Comptroller --
"IMMEDIATE ATTENTION REQUIRED..."

April 30, 2021 e-mail from Assemblyman Burdick's chief of staff

Assembly's May 10, 2021 e-mail

Assembly's May 13, 2021 response -- enclosed contract

CJA's May 14, 2021 appeal

CJA's May 24, 2021 follow-up e-mail regarding appeal

Assembly's May 24, 2021 response with justification

CJA's May 24, 2021 FOIL request to Assembly --
"Speaker Heastie's direction to the Assembly Judiciary Committee & mandate to Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP
 regarding the impeachment investigation of Governor Cuomo"



2.
CJA's CORRESPONDENCE WITH DAVIS POLK

CJA's April 7, 2021 e-mail --
"Voice mail left on your hotline, 212-450-3600, on April 5th,
pertaining to impeachable acts by Gov. Cuomo,
starting with insertion of the immunity provision for nursing homes/hospitals in the 2020 budget"

linking to: CJA's webpage for immunity provision

CJA's April 7, 2021 e-mail --
"The mountain of open-&-shut, prima facie EVIDENCE of Gov. Cuomo's impeachable criminal conduct,
laid out by CJA's June 4, 2020 grand jury/public corruption complaint to Albany DA Soares &
March 5, 2021 conflict-of-interest/ethics complaint to JCOPE"

attaching: CJA's March 18, 2020 letter to Governor Cuomo

CJA's 62 public corruption/grand jury complaints to NYS' 64 D.A. --
starting with Albany D.A. Soares

CJA's March 5, 2021 conflict-of-interest/ethics complaint to JCOPE/LEC


CJA's April 29, 2021 e-mail
--
"STATUS: Your investigation of CJA's April 7, 2021 e-mail, furnishing open-&-shut,
prima facie EVIDENCE of Gov. Cuomo's impeachable, criminal conduct"  auto-reply

CJA's May 25, 2021 e-mail --
"Tomorrow's Assembly Judiciary Committee meeting --
& your duties under your contract with the Assembly,
owed to & paid by, the People of the State of New York"

 

* * *

WHO ARE THE 21 ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY COMMITTEE MEMBERS --
& what they knew, when... 
click here for: VIDEO & PAPER TRAIL, since 2011

CHAIR: Charles Lavine, ESQ.  [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/13th AD]
newly-appointed chair, but Committee member since Jan. 2011,
in other words, since he was first elected in Nov. 2010


RANKING MEMBERMichael Montesano, ESQ. [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/15th AD]
Committee member since his Feb. 2010 special election to the Assembly,
ranking member from 2014-2016, & in 2021.

MEMBERS:
Thomas Abinanti, ESQ. member since 2018 [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/92nd AD]
Edward Braunstein, ESQ., member since at least 2011 [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/26th AD]
Keith Brown, ESQ., member since 2021   [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/12th AD]
Marjorie Byrnes, ESQ., member since 2019  [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/133rd AD]
Catalina Cruz, ESQ.,
member since 2021 [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/39th AD]
Latoya Joyner, ESQ., member since 2015  [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/77th AD]
Karen McMahon, ESQ., elected Nov. 2018, not in 2019 [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/146th AD]
Marcela Mitaynes, member since 2021 [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/51st AD]
Michael J. Norris, ESQ.member since 2019 [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/144th AD]
Dan Quart, ESQ., member since 2012
[CJA's 2021 webpage for him/73rd AD]
Jenifer Rajkumar, ESQ., member since 2021 [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/38th AD]
Rebecca Seawright, ESQ.,
member since 2015  [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/76th AD]
Phil Steck, ESQ., member since 2013 
[CJA's 2021 webpage for him/110th AD]
Michael Tannousis, ESQ.,
member since 2021 [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/64th AD]
Latrice Walker, ESQ., elected special election 2014, not in 2019 [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/55th AD]
Monica P. Wallace, ESQ., member since 2019  [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/143rd AD]
Mary Beth Walsh, ESQ.,member since 2019  [CJA's 2021 webpage for her/112th AD]
David Weprin, ESQ.member since at least 2008 [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/24th AD]
Kenneth Zebrowski, ESQ., member since at least 2008  [CJA's 2021 webpage for him/96th AD]


* * *

HERE's THE PUBLIC FACE
OF THE ASSEMBLY's IMPEACHMENT INQUIRY


March 11, 2021 announcement
"Statement of Speaker Carl Heastie on Authorizing
Assembly Judiciary Committee to Begin Investigation into Governor Cuomo
"

March 17, 2021 announcement
"Speaker Heastie and Judiciary Committee Chair Lavine Announce
the Hiring of Davis Polk and Wardwell, LLC to Lead Impeachment Investigation
of Governor's Conduct
"


March 23, 2021
AUDIO -- meeting with Davis, Polk lawyers

DAVIS POLK & WARDWELL LLP  Greg Andres, ESQ.; Angela Burgess, ESQ.; Martine Beamon, ESQ.

New York State Constitution, Article VI, Sec. 24
"Court for trial of impeachments; judgment"

NYS Constitution, Article XIII, Sec. 5
"removal from office for misconduct"

"New York's Impeachment Law and the Trial of Governor Sulzer: A Case for Reform"
Fordham Law Review  (1987) (John Dunne, Michael Balboni)

Judiciary Law, Article 7-A (secs. 240-248)

April 1, 2021
"Judiciary Committee Chair Lavine Announces Details
of Hotline for Assembly Investigation of Governor's Conduct
"


April 16, 2021 statement by Chair Lavine

April 21, 2021 statement by Chair Lavine

 

April 21, 2021
AUDIO -- meeting with Davis, Polk lawyers

here's another DAVIS POLK lawyer -- Uzo Asonye, ESQ.

 

May 25, 2021
AUDIO -- meeting with Davis, Polk lawyers

 

-----------------------


* * *

May 14, 2021
"Assembly's Cuomo impeachment investigation costs are capped"
WGRZ News (Jeff Preval)

May 14, 2021
"$250K legal contract for Cuomo impeachment probe is not nearly enough, critics say"
New York Post (Bernadette Hogan, Bruce Golding)

May 19, 2021
"The Cuomo Impeachment Probe Is A Sham"
National Review (Andrew McCarthy)

May 26, 2021
Cuomo Impeachment Probe Advances:
75 Witnesses Contacted, ‘Tens Of Thousands’ Of Documents Reviewed
"

Forbes (Jemima McEvoy)

May 26, 2021
"NY Assemblyman Lavine defends contact in brief update of Cuomo impeachment probe"
Daily News (Denis Slattery)

May 26, 2021
"Assembly impeachment investigation of Cuomo moving slowly"
NY-1 (Morgan McKay)

May 26, 2021
"Cuomo Impeachment Investigation Has Now Spoken To Around 75 People"
NBC-4

May 26, 2021
"Cuomo Impeachment Probe Moving Forward, Hundreds of Tips Roll In"
Bloomberg (Emma Kinery, with assistance Keshia Clukey)

May 26, 2021
"Assembly Democrat insists that $250,000 for Cuomo impeachment just for starters"
NY Post (Bernadette Hogan)

May 26, 2021
"Cuomo used Speaker Heastie in bid to silence Cuomo critic as Post exposed COVID cover-up"
NY Post (Bernadette Hogan, Bruce Golding)

May 27, 2021
Cuomo’s Impeachment Inquiry Accused of Slow-Walking Its Probe
Bloomberg (Emma Kinery)

May 27, 2021
"Cuomo's Political Path Brightens as Impeachment Inquiry Drags On"
Bloomberg (Emma Kinery, with Keshia Clukey & Erik Larson)

updated, with 7th paragraph comments by Sen. Biaggi:
“The Assembly has had more than enough reason to draft articles of impeachment and begin impeachment hearings in the Senate as written in our Constitution. The Assembly Judiciary Committee’s investigation is simply an attempt to appease and buy time for the Governor, rather than holding him accountable for his actions,” said state Senator Alessandra Biaggi. “The lack of movement and transparency in the judiciary committee’s investigation only proves that point.”

May 27, 2021
"Could the Cuomo Investigation Taint Davis Polk?"
Bloomberg (Vivia Chen)

 

-----------

March 17, 2021
"Governor Cuomo's Office Hires Outside Lawyers to Handle Probe"
Bloomberg Law (Joel Rosenblatt)

March 23, 2021
"Cuomo Impeachment Kicks Off With Hearing, Tip Line"
Bloomberg (Emma Kinery, Patricia Hurtado)

April 7, 2021
"Embattled Governor Passes Late Budget, Concedes on Wealth Taxes"
Bloomberg (Henry Goldman, Donna Borak, Keshia Clukey)

April 21, 2021
"Cuomo Impeachment Hotline Has Gotten 200 Calls, Assemblyman Says"
Bloomberg News (Keshia Clukey)

May 13, 2021
"Cuomo Hired Lawyers In Outside Scandal Without Saying Who Will Pay"
Bloomberg Law (Emma Kinery)


 

 

Top

 
 
CJA Site Search Engine Search CJA

CJA Homepage  •  Latest News  •  Join Us  •  Site Search

 

 

Mailing Address:
Post Office Box 8101, White Plains, New York 10602
Tel: 914-421-1200
e-mail: mail@judgewatch.org