About CJA
Our History
Our Mission
Who We Are
Awards & Honors

Published Pieces

Testimony

Judicial Selection
Federal
State-NY

Judicial Discipline
Federal
State-NY

Test Cases:
Federal (Mangano)
State (Commission)

"Disruption of Congress"
Paper Trail to Jail
Paper Trail from Jail
The Appeals

Judicial Compensation
Federal
State-NY

Elections:
Informing the Voters

Press Suppression

Suing The New York Times
Outreach
Background Paper Trail

Searching for Champions:
    (Correspondence):

Federal
NYS
Bar Associations
Academia
Organizations
Nader & Others
Citizens

Our Members' Efforts

Library

Join Us!

A TALE OF THREE LAWSUITS: 
PRESS REPORTING REPORTING & EDITORIALIZING

 CJA's OUTREACH TO PRESS ABOUT CJA v. JCOPE, et al.
June 2022    July 2022    January 2025-amicus curiae


#1
CJA v. JCOPE, et al -- SOLE ARTICLE

June 13, 2022
"Citizens' Group Seeks To Void Repeal And Replacement of NY Ethics Watchdog"
New York Law Journal (Brian Lee)

* * *

#2
September 26, 2022
"Lawsuit seeks to strike key plank of new ethics law"
Albany Times Union (Chris Bragg)

September 26, 2022
"New ethics commission faces lawsuit and criticism"
News 10-WABC (Amal Tlaige)

October 3, 2022
"Lawsuit challenges committee's confirmation power to New York's new ethics commission"
Spectrum (Ryan Whalen)

October 7, 2022
"Lawsuit challenges confidentiality of ethics commission"
News 10-WABC (Amal Tlaige)  news@news10.comJDeLine@news10.com 

April 26, 2023
"Cuomo sues ethics panel saying its creation was flawed"
Albany Times Union (Joshua Solomon)

April 26, 2023
"Cuomo, who specialized in controlling ethics commissions,
sues existing ethics commission for being too controlling of the governor
"
City & State (Shantel Destra)

April 26, 2023
"Andrew Cuomo lawsuit says state has no authority to take his book millions"
New York Post (Zach Williams)

June 2, 2023
"Disgraced ex NY Gov. Andrew Cuomo fights in court
to keep $5M from COVID book
"
NY Post (Zach Williams) 

June 29, 2023
"The Constitutionality of the Commission on Ethics and Lobbying in Government"
Gov't Law Center/Albany Law School (Bennett Liebman)

September 11, 2023
"NY Ethics Agency in Doubt after Andrew Cuomo Lawsuit Win (1)"
Bloomberg Law (Zach Williams)

To contact the reporter on this story: Zach Williams at zwilliams@bloombergindustry.com

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Fawn Johnson at fjohnson@bloombergindustry.com; Stephanie Gleason at sgleason@bloombergindustry.com


September 11, 2023

"
Cuomo wins lawsuit, leaves New York without ethics watchdog"
Politico (Bill Mahoney)

September 11, 2023
"
Cuomo Wins Book Lawsuit, Leaving New York's ethics panel in Limbo"
New York Times (Grace Ashford)

September 11, 2023
"Judge rules in favor of Cuomo's bid to keep book money, neuter ethics board"
Daily News (Tim Balk)

September 11, 2023
"Ex-Gov Andrew Cuomo notches big winwith bombshell ruling that deems

NY ethics panel probing his $5M COVID book deal ‘unconstitutional
"
New York Post (Carl Campanile, Ben Kochman)

September 11, 2023
"
The New York ethics commission that pursued former Govenor Cuomo
is unconstitutional, a judge says
"
AP (Michael Hill)   The Independent

September 11, 2023
"
Judge strikes down New York state ethics panel"
Public Radio (Karen DeWitt)  NY-NOW

September 11, 2023
"
Court decision upends New York ethics oversight"
Spectrum News (Kate Lisa)

September 11, 2023
"
Cuomo wins lawsuit disbanding Albany's ethics watchdog body"
Buffalo News (Chris Bragg)

September 11, 2023
"
Andrew Cuomo scores $5 M court Victory in Legal Upset"
Newsweek (Katherine Fung)

September 11, 2023
"
Albany judge deems state ethics panel unconstitutional in Cuomo book case"
AM-NY - Politics NY (Ethan Stark-Miller)

September 11, 2023
"
Cuomo wins initial legal fight to unravel new ethics commission"
City & State (Vaughn Golden)

September 11, 2023
"
Reinvent Albany advisor on ruling that NYS ethics commission is unconstitutional"

Spectrum News (Casey Bortnick)

September 11, 2023
"Cuomo wins lawsuit disbanding Albany's ethics watchdog"
Buffalo News (Chris Bragg)

"Suit spurs talk of constitutional ethics change"
Spectrum News (Kate Lisa)

September 12, 2023
"Albany and ethics never mix.
A judge knocking down the state watchdog is due to the sloppy way it was created
"
Daily News (editorial)

September 12, 2023
"New Yorkers need a say on state ethics panel"
Newsday (editorial)

"New York court rules state ethics commission unconstitutional"
Jurist  (Rebekah Yeager-Malken)

September 18, 2023
"Cuomo wins another round to protect his multi-million dollar book deal"
WAMC-Public Radio (Blair Horner)

"A dead watchdog?"
Albany Times Union (editorial)

September 19, 2023
"The battle for oversight in Albany has suffered a severe setback"
Buffalo News (editorial)

September 27, 2023
"Ethics commission meets after judge ruled its unconstituitonal"
Albany Times Union (Brendan Lyons)

September 27, 2023
"NY ethics watchdog eyes more state funding amid ethics freeze"
Spectrum New (Kate Lisa)

October 1, 2023
"Give NYers an ethics watchdog they can trust"
New York Post (editorial)

February 16, 2024
"New York Appeals Court Hears Arguments Over the Fate of the State's Ethics Panel"
AP -- US News (Michael Hill)   PBS

February 16, 2024
"Appellate court hears Cuomo challenge to fledgling ethics agency"
Albany Times Union (Dan Clark)

February 16, 2024
"Next on Cuomo's Rehabilitation Tour: Blowing Up a State Ethics Panel"
New York Times (Grace Ashford)

February 21, 2024
"New York State's Ethics Commission Facing Judicial Test"
Insurance Journal  (Michael Hill)

March 11, 2024
"NY Appellate Courts Mull Markedly Differing Lawsuits
Questioning State Ethics Watchdog
"
NYLJ (Brian Lee)

March 15, 2024
"Future of NY's ethics body nears"
Politico (Bill Mahoney)

April 8, 2024
"Fourth Department Hears Arguments in Lawsuit Against NY's Ethics Watchdog"
NYLJ (Brian Lee)

May 9, 2024
"New York Ethics Panel Violates State Constitution, Appeals Court Rules"
New York Times (Grace Ashford)

May 9, 2024
"Appellate court sides with Cuomo, ruling ethics panel is unconstitutional"
Albany Times Union (Brendan Lyon)

May 9, 2024
"Cuomo wins another court battle against New York's ethics watchdog"
Politico (Bill Mahoney)
 

May 9, 2024
"New York appeals court rules ethics commission
that pursued Cuomo was created unconstitutionally
"
AP (Michael Hill)   also Post-Star

May 9, 2024
"Appellate court agrees that state ethics commission is unconstitutional"
City & State (Rebecca Lewis)

May 10, 2024
"Common Cause blasts COELIG ruling as 'authoritarian'"
Spectrum (Susan Arbetter)

May 13, 2024
"Appeal court rules against NY ethics commission"
Press Republican (Alex Gault)

May 23, 2024
"Ethics commission's fate still in limbo"
Newsday

May 29, 2024
"Act now for a lasting ethics fix"
Daily Star (editorial)  -- Albany Times Union May 16th editorial

May 29, 2024
"There's a vetting -- and vexing problem -- with New York's laws"
Albany Times Union (editorial)

May 30, 2024
"Former senator fighting forcible kissing case takes Cuomo's path"
Albany Times Union (Brendan Lyons)

May 31, 2024
"Ethics Commission Subpoenaed Hochul Administration Over Bills Box Seats"
Focus (Chris Bragg)

June 10, 2024
"Judge ices ethics commission's case against former IDC leader"
Albany Times Union (Brendan Lyons)

July 3, 2024
"Attorney Nominated to Ethics Panel as Its Validity is Before NY's Top Court"
NYLJ (Brian Lee)

July 3, 2024
"Hochul names latest nominee to Commission on Ethics and Lobbying in Government"
Spectrum News (Luke Parsnow)

July 3, 2024
"Hochul nominates ethics commissioner as the panel's future in limbo"
Albany Times Union (Brendan Lyons)

September 25, 2024
"New York state ethics panel names new chair, vice chair"
Spectrum News (Luke Parsnow)

October 1, 2024
"A state with too few watchdogs"
Albany Times Union (editorial)

November 18-19, 2024
"Fate of Ethics Panel and Cuomo Book Deal Probe Is in Top Court's Hands
as January Arguments Approach
"
NYLJ (Brian Lee)

November 22, 2024
"In Brief: Why Can't New York Build an Effective Ethics Agency?"
NY Focus (Chris Bragg)

November 26, 2024
"An introduction to COELIG, NY's ethics watchdog"
Spectrum News (Susan Arbetter)

November 29, 2024
"Watchdogs: NYS needs more robust ethics commission"
Public News Service (Edwin Viera)

November 29, 2024
"N.Y. ethics commissions faces new constitutional challenge"
Albany Times Union (Brendan Lyons)

December 6, 2024
"Fix Ethics Lapse"
Albany Times Union (editorial)

December 21, 2024
"Another Voice: Ongoing legal challenge to Hochul not without merit"
Buffalo News (Opinion, Joseph T. Burns, Esq.)

January 7, 2025
"Albany ethics watchdog needs teeth:
Replace the current commission which is unconstitutional
"
Daily News (editorial)

"We want a strong ethics enforcer for the state government,
so we hope that the state’s highest court throws out the weak body now in place
,...
Reading the briefs and decisions it is very clear that the earlier ethics agency,
JCOPE, also had the exact same constitutional defect, as the governor appointed only six of its 14 members. ..."


January 7, 2025
Andrew Cuomo Is Using the Conservative Playbook to Fight a State Ethics Probe
Balls & Strikes (Steve Kennedy, Esq.)

"...Ultimately, the right's attacks on functioning government have provided unscrupulous actors with a script to undermine agency action.  It is disappointing -- if not surprising -- to see a Democratic politican who once said 'I am the left,' and who wrote a book about 'leadership lessons,' try to take down the only independent ethics agency in his state to save his own ass." (underlining added)


January 7, 2025
"Can Cuomo convince New York's highest court to scrap state ethics commission"
City & State (Austin Jefferson)

"Good government organizations are hoping that the independent watchdog agency
survives this last-gasp appeal for the sake of government accountability...
Representatives from watchdog groups...have kept close tabs on courtroom proceedings in the case against COELIG,
seeing it as a defining moment for the future of ethics in New York politics...
'We want independent entitites that look out for the public's best interest and if, essentially,
the governor can't cede anything independent, then as you've heard, ethics enforcement is left up to the leaders,'
said Blair Horner, senior policy advisor at the New York Public Interest Research Group..."


January 7, 2025
"NY Ethics Board That Probed Cuomo Criticized by Top State Court"
Bloomberg (Beth Wong)
bwang@bloombergindustry.com

January 7, 2025
"New York ethics commissions pushes for overturning
Cuomo's challenge disbanding independent watchdog
"

Courthouse News Service (Josh Russell)
newyork@courthousenews.com

January 7, 2025
"Court decision on Cuomo ethics commission under scrutiny, appeal"
Albany News 10 (Johan Sheridan)  Rochester
& here

January 7, 2025
"Constitutionality of New York's ethics panel argued before state's top court"
AP (Michael Hill)  KTAR-Arizona Independent   Yahoo  WRVO - Jan 8  WSKG -- Jan 8


"more independent setup...But Rachel Fauss of Reinvent Albany, who listened to arguments with other good-government advocates, said that a ruling agains the commission could upend ethics enforcement in New York. 'There would be no watchdog on the beat,' she said.  'We've had a history of...corrption scandals in this state, and all the bodies have been ill-equipped to handle them.  And if this one -- this new body that's the most independent we've had yet -- is thrown out, I think it raises a big question about what the Legislature would come up with."

January 7, 2025
"Cuomo vs. state ethics commission goes to the Court of Appeals
with separation of powers under scrutiny
"
Spectrum News (Jack Arpey)

"Good-government groups who have defended COELIG...said the current case is preventing ethics complaints from moving forward, and a ruling in Cuomo's favor would further plunge the state's ethics enforcement into an indefinite state of limbo. 
Regardless of the outcome, Rick Schaffer, who wrote the amicus brief on behalf of the organizations, said they are pushing for even more independence for ethics enforcement...'That would include the possibility of having judges serve on an ethics commission..."

January 7, 2025
"NY's high court weighs constitutionality of state ethics panel"
Albany Times Union (Brendan Lyons)



-------------------------------

 

click here for
2022 snapshot -- JCOPE

2022 snapshot -- COELIG

2023 snapshot -- COELIG

2024 snapshot -- COELIG

 

 

 
 

Top

 
CJA Site Search Engine Search CJA

CJA Homepage  •  Latest News  •  Join Us  •  Site Search

 

Post Office Box 8101, White Plains, New York 10602
Tel: (914) 421-1200
e-mail: mail@judgewatch.org