CJA's SECOND Citizen-Taxpayer Action --
to End NYS' Corrupt Budget "Process"
& Unconstitutional "Three Men in a Room" Governance

Plaintiffs' May 15, 2017 REPLY

Plaintiffs' May 15, 2017 Reply Memorandum of Law

Plaintiff Sassower's May 15, 2017 reply affidavit

Exhibit 4-a:     Plaintiff Sassower’s April 28, 2017 letter to Judge Hartman 

Exhibit 4-b:     Judge Hartman’s May 5, 2017 so-ordered letter

Exhibit 5:        Transcript of March 29, 2017 oral argument

Exhibit 6:        Correspondence preceding March 29, 2017 oral argument

Exhibit 6-a:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 24, 2017 letter to Judge Hartman

Exhibit 6-b:     Judge Hartman’s March 24, 2017 letter

Exhibit 6-c:     March 24, 2017 e-mail from Litigation Bureau Chief Jeffrey Dvorin (1:03 pm)

Exhibit 6-d:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 24, 2017 e-mail to Chief Dvorin (1:33 pm)

Exhibit 6-e:     Chief Dvorin’s March 24, 2017 e-mail (1:44 pm)

Exhibit 6-f:      Plaintiff Sassower’s March 24, 2017 e-mail to Chief Dvorin (4:03 pm)

Exhibit 6-g:     Chief Dvorin’s March 24, 2017 e-mail  (4:28 pm)

Exhibit 6-h:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 24, 2017 e-mail to Chief Dvorin (4:48 pm)

Exhibit 6-i:      Plaintiff Sassower’s March 27, 2017 e-mail to Chief Dvorin (2:38 pm)

Exhibit 6-j:      Chief Dvorin’s March 27, 2017 e-mail (2:38 pm)

Exhibit 6-k:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 27, 2017 e-mail (2:43 pm)

Exhibit 6-l:      Chief Dvorin’s March 27, 2017 e-mail (2:51 pm)

Exhibit 6-m:    Plaintiff Sassower’s March 27, 2017 e-mail to Deputy AG Meg Levine (3:07 pm)

Exhibit 6-n:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 28, 2017 e-mail to Judge Hartman  (9:54 am)

Exhibit 6-o:     Judge Hartman’s March 28, 2017 letter

Exhibit 6-p:     Deputy AG Levine’s March 28, 2017 e-mail  (10:13 am)

Exhibit 6-q:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 28, 2017 e-mail to Deputy AG Levine (10:38 am)

Exhibit 6-r:      Plaintiff Sassower’s March 28, 2017 e-mail  (11:29 am)

Exhibit 7:        Correspondence following March 29, 2017 oral argument

Exhibit 7-a:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 30, 2017 e-mail to Judge Hartman (11:20 am)

Exhibit 7-b:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 30, 2017 e-mail to Deputy AG Levine  (1:35 pm)

Exhibit 7-c:     AAG Lynch’s March 30, 2017 e-mail with letter to Judge Hartman  (1:38 pm)

Exhibit 7-d:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 30, 2017 e-mail to AAG Lynch  (3:08 pm)

Exhibit 7-e:     Plaintiff Sassower’s March 31, 2017 e-mail to Attorney General Schneiderman, Chief Deputy Attorney General Jason Brown, Chief Deputy Attorney General Janet Sabel, Executive Deputy Attorney General Kent Stauffer (3:02 pm)

Exhibit 7-f:      Judge Hartman’s March 31, 2017 letter

Exhibit 7-g:     Plaintiff Sassower’s April 2, 2017 e-mail to Attorney General Schneiderman  (11:16 am)

Exhibit 7-h:     Plaintiff Sassower’s April 5, 2017 e-mail to Attorney General Schneiderman (10:50 am)

Exhibit 8-a:     Plaintiffs’ March 24, 2017 FOIL request to Senate – “March 13, 2017 ‘amending’ of Governor Cuomo’s budget bills for fiscal year 2017-2018”     

Exhibit 8-b:     Senate’s March 31, 2017 e-mail

Exhibit 8-c:     Plaintiff Sassower’s April 4, 2017 letter

Exhibit 8-d:     Plaintiff Sassower’s April 28, 2017 letter, with enclosure

Exhibit 8-e:     Senate’s May 5, 2017 e-mail

Exhibit 9-a:     Plaintiffs’ March 24, 2017 FOIL request to Senate – “March 12, 2016 ‘amending’ of Governor Cuomo’s budget bills for fiscal year 2016-2017”     

Exhibit 9-b:     Senate’s March 31, 2017 e-mail

Exhibit 9-c:     Plaintiff Sassower’s May 4, 2017 letter

Exhibit 9-d:     Senate’s May 11, 2017 e-mail

Exhibit 10-a:   Plaintiffs’ March 27, 2017 FOIL request to Senate – “March 20, 2017 ‘amending’ of Governor Cuomo’s Debt Service Budget Bill #S.2002 for fiscal year 2017-2018”

Exhibit 10-b:   Senate’s April 3, 2017 e-mail

Exhibit 10-c:   Plaintiff Sassower’s May 4, 2017 letter

Exhibit 11-a:   Plaintiffs’ March 24, 2017 FOIL request to Assembly – “March 13, 2017 ‘amending’ of Governor Cuomo’s budget bills for fiscal year 2017-2018” 

Exhibit 11-b:   Assembly’s March 30, 2017 letter

Exhibit 11-c:   Plaintiff Sassower’s May 4, 2017 letter

Exhibit 11-d:   Assembly’s May 11, 2017 letter

Exhibit 12-a:   Plaintiffs’ March 24, 2017 FOIL request to Assembly – “March 11, 2016 ‘amending’ of Governor Cuomo’s budget bills for fiscal year 2016-2017” 

Exhibit 12-b:   Assembly’s March 30, 2017 letter

Exhibit 12-c:   Plaintiff Sassower’s May 4, 2017 letter

Exhibit 12-d:   Assembly’s May 11, 2017 letter

Exhibit 13-a:   Plaintiffs’ March 27, 2017 FOIL request to Assembly – “March 20, 2017 ‘amending’ of Governor Cuomo’s Debt Service Budget Bill #A.3002 for fiscal year 2017-2018”

Exhibit 13-b:   Assembly’s April 3, 2017 letter

Exhibit 13-c:   Assembly’s April 13, 2017 e-mail

Exhibit 13-d:   Plaintiff Sassower’s May 4, 2017 letter

Exhibit 13-e:   Assembly’s May 11, 2017 letter

Exhibit 14-a:   1^st page – enacted (3-men-in-a-room) State Operations Budget Bill #S.2000-d /A.3000-d

Exhibit 14-b:   Illustrative comparisons of appropriations/reappropriations in State Operations Budget Bills #S.2000/A.3000 (Governor’s); #S.2000-b (Senate); #A.3000-b (Assembly); #S.2000-d/A.3000-d (3-men-in-a-room)

Exhibit 15-a:   1^st page – enacted (3-men-in-a-room) Aid to Localities Budget Bill  #S.2003-d/A.3003-d

Exhibit 15-b:   Illustrative comparisons of appropriations/reappropriations in Aid to Localities Budget Bills #S.2003/A.3003 (Governor’s); #S.2003-b (Senate); #A.3003-b (Assembly); #S.2003-d/A.3003-d (3-men-in-a-room)

*   *   *

Plaintiffs' May 19, 2017 letter to Chief Court Clerk
with subpoena duces tecum for Senate
with subboena duces teum for Assembly

    AAG Kerwin's May 23, 2017 letter to Judge Hartman

click here for: 
CJA's Citizen-Taxpayer Actions to End NYS' Corrupt Budget "Process"
& Unconstitutional "Three Men in a Room" Governance 

CJA Homepage  •  Latest News  •  Join Us  •  Site Search

Post Office Box 8101, White Plains, New York 10602 Tel: (914) 421-1200 e-mail: mail@judgewatch.org